Siesta Key Restaurants & Dining

Something for everyone
The Beach Deli at Crescent Beach Grocery

The Beach Deli at Crescent Beach Grocery
Phone: (941) 312-0472
Address: 1211 Old Stickney Pt. Rd.

The Beach Deli is your source for great food such as freshly made-to-order sandwiches, chef-made salads and ready to-go meals. We only serve the highest quality lunch meats and cheeses and our staff will gladly prepare one of our signature sandwiches or one of your own creations. Our deli case is stacked with slabs of slow cooked ribs, meat loaf, cooked chickens, crab cakes, twice-baked potatoes and freshly baked bagels and muffins. A steak or chop from our meat case, paired with one of our salads, will provide a sunset barbecue you will remember.
Big Water Fish Market

Big Water Fish MarketPhone: (941) 554-8101
Address: 6641 Midnight Pass Rd.

"Our Fish is Delish" Big Water Fish Market is the only fresh fish market on Siesta Key - we get fresh fish in daily. In addition to fresh fish, we feature lunchtime favorites including Mad Mikes Tuna Salad Sandwich, and Siesta Shrimp Salad. Call ahead to have your lunch order ready. We also carry local spices, sauces and many breakfast items including eggs, juice and bacon. Specialty items available include Clam Bake to Go, Oyster Roast to Go, Beach Picnic Baskets, and more. Open Mon-Sat 10-6, Sun 11-4.
Clayton's Siesta Grille

Clayton's Siesta Grille Phone: (941) 349-2800
Address: 1256 Old Stickney Pt Rd.

A nice place to relax and enjoy great food. Clayton's Siesta Grille offers island casual with a touch of Mediterranean fiery elegance. Indoor and outdoor dining, fresh seafood, a friendly bar with a daily happy hour.
Der Dutchman Restaurant

Der Dutchman RestaurantPhone: (941) 955-8007
Address: 3713 Bahia Vista St.

Amish Kitchen Cooking. At Der Dutchman restaurant it's really pretty simple. We take the basics and make them extraordinary. From our broasted chicken and tender roast beef to our warm homemade bread, real mashed potatoes, and home-style noodles and dressing, everything is made to perfection. Our fresh salad bar is always full of your garden favorites. Our own in-house bakery will never disappoint your sweet tooth with our wide assortment of pies and pastries baked fresh daily. So what's so simple about all this? It's simply delicious and simply a great value.
Javier’s Restaurant & Wine Bar

Javier’s Restaurant & Wine BarPhone: (941) 349-1792
Address: 6621 Midnight Pass Road - Crescent Plaza

A charming, unique restaurant re-creating a Peruvian village cafe in the Andes Mountains. Lush, plant filled dining room featuring Peruvian art, crafts and tapestries. Cozy wine bar with excellent South American and New World wines and imported Peruvian beers. The combination of creative Peruvian preparations or classic American favorites assure something for everyone’s taste. Open Tuesday through Saturday from 5:00 pm. Reservations always appreciated.
The Lobster Pot

The Lobster Pot Phone: (941) 349-2323
Address: 5157 Ocean Blvd.

Located on Siesta Key, we bring you the finest tastes of New England. Enjoy a delightful dining experience in our main dining room or our patio. Open Monday thru Saturday from 11:30am.
Morgans Restaurant

Morgan's Restaurant Phone: (941) 966-2121
Address: 1660 South Tamiami Trail

Enjoy a relaxing evening at Morgan's Restaurant or have a lunch or dinner at our Tiki Bar & Grillzebo. Early bird specials and happy hour seven days a week. We feature live entertainment Friday through Sunday. Check out our website for details.
Old Salty Dog

Old Salty Dog Phone: (941) 349-0158
Address: 5023 Ocean Blvd.

Serving Sarasota for over 20 years, the Old Salty Dog mixes the best of the Florida Keys with our British heritage to create a fun family environment. Menu items include appetizers, burgers, fries and traditional English fish and chips. Try our famous “Salty Dog” - a 1/4 lb. hot dog dipped in beer batter and deep fried - delicious! Bring your laptopy - we are a wi-fi hot spot. Open 7 days a week from 11am.
Ophelia’s On The Bay

Ophelia’s On The Bay Phone: (941) 349-2212
Address: 9105 Midnight Pass Rd.

Ophelia’s on the Bay is Sarasota’s finest waterfront restaurant now in its 17th season. The restaurant gives you eyelevel views of Little Sarasota Bay and is framed by tropical vegetation and flower gardens. Ophelia’s offers a blend of cuisines, with a new minu nightly using the freshest local fish and produce available. Reservations suggested.
Turtles Restaurant

Turtles Restaurant Phone: (941) 346-2207
Address: 8875 Midnight Pass Rd.

Good food in a charming atmosphere overlooking little Sarasota Bay. Indoor and outdoor dining, along with seasonal entertainment. Offering only the freshest seafood and other fine cuisine at reasonable prices in a casual, friendly atmosphere. Open daily, happy hour served 3:30-7pm.
Village Cafe

Village Cafe Phone: (941) 349-2822
Address: 5133 Ocean Blvd.

Nestled in the heart of Siesta Key Village, our menu offers only the finest selection of breakfast and lunch specialties anywhere on the Florida Gulf Coast. Dine inside or outside on our open air patio. Open 7am-2:30pm daily. Call ahead for carryout.